bossymarmalade: west indies in command: rejects FAIL (yuh dotish or wha?)
miss maggie ([personal profile] bossymarmalade) wrote2010-06-14 04:06 pm

i thought you were some kind of outer-space potato man

You might have seen people talking about the J2 story set in the aftermath of the earthquake in Haiti -- written, in fact, while they were still pulling out bodies from the rubble and the news was covering the disaster.

I am fiercely protective of my West Indies/Caribbean, and so I read it. I don't recommend you do the same. But if you're curious, here's some of the bits I had a hard time with.

Abraham Joseph, the black Haitian helping Dr. Jensen:
- A huge, white grin flashed in his direction. “No go slow,” Abraham said. “Not know how.”

Jensen met the man’s dark, intense eyes. It was hard to believe sometimes that Abraham was a nurse. Six foot five if an inch. Nearly 300 pounds. Hands the size of Frisbees. Amazingly calm under pressure, though if pushed, had a temper like a solar flare. But Jensen had seen him in action, had seen the compassion in his eyes and hands, had heard it in his voice. He’d seen the mountain reduced to rubble at the sight of a dying child. Had seen those giant hands provide comfort with the lightest of touches.


- A tiny woman with white coffee skin ran up to them the second the jeep lurched to a stop outside the crumbling walls of the village. Her hair was wrapped in a red scarf, her dress a collection of orange scraps that hugged her body.
note: the accompanying art (since amended) used photographs of actual earthquake victims


- For his part, Jensen took charge of his impromptu exam room, opening his knapsack and organizing his supplies ... Condoms. Abraham had laughed the first time he’d seen those in Jensen’s bag, shoving the first two fingers of one hand through the circle created by the thumb and forefinger of the other as he wiggled his eyebrows suggestively.

“Hanky panky,” he’d said.

“HIV,” Jensen had replied.


- Jensen was listening to an old woman’s heart when he felt a hand slip into the pocket on the side of his leg. It was Abraham replenishing Jensen’s supply of latex gloves. And with a hand as large as his, a single handful filled Jensen’s pocket to bulging.
note: there is almost no mention of abraham that doesn't include marvelling at how unnaturally huge he is


- Jensen smiled at the old woman. Her hair was streaked with gray and the skin of her face was like leather. She wore a kind expression. Guileless. Jensen had a sudden urge to wrap his arms around her and hold her close. She reminded him vaguely of a kindly old grandmother and he wondered if beneath it all, she smelled like cloves.


- Jensen looked at the woman again. She met his eyes and smiled, revealing a mouthful of bad dental work. He knew she had to be feeling terrible, but she would never complain ... That seemed to be the way of these people: bear your burden in silence and when you couldn’t take it anymore, bear it some more.


- Tears welled in her eyes then, falling silently down her cheeks as her fingers gripped the baby’s blanket. Ducking her head, she pulled the baby away from her chest and pressed her lips to the tiny forehead. “Bebe mwen,” she whispered. My baby. “Bebe mwen.” ... “She smothered him,” he said, the wind and the engine roar carrying his words away. The baby’s lips were blue. There was blood around his nose. He had petechial hemorrhages around his irises. Jensen didn’t know for sure, but he was fairly certain.


- But when he’d arrived, he was simply one of two hundred other doctors with the same idea. The problem became too many chiefs and not enough indians.


- “You guys are kinda famous around the camp, you know. The dashing American doctor and his trusty Haitian sidekick, driving around the country in an Army jeep, healing the sick and generally making the world safe for democracy, one band aid at a time. It’s a great story.”


- The rug had been a gift from a woman in one of the villages. She’d handed it to him in a tight roll, nodding profusely as she gibbered away in Creole.


- “The nearest doctor was thirty miles away,” Geraldine said to them. “But he’s gone now. He left Haiti after the earthquake. He left his own people.” ... She laid a hand on his arm and smiled. “It is a blessing from God that Abraham brought you to us today.” She closed her eyes and tilted her head towards the ceiling for a long moment, a serene look on her face. Then she looked back at him. “Amen,” she muttered under her breath, her fingers squeezing his arm. She smiled again. “Yes.” She nodded. “A blessing.”


- “Look,” he said, standing. “I don’t have to keep justifying myself to you. And I don’t believe I need your permission to be here. Last time I checked, you weren’t the keeper of the gates to Haiti.” This close up, Abraham’s size was striking. Jared was used to being the tallest one in a group, but Abraham was taller by at least two inches, maybe more. It was a bit disorienting - and intimidating - to have to look up to meet his eyes.

The thing was, he expected to find anger in them. Or at the very least, suspicion. But what he found was something else entirely. Fatigue. Sadness. Concern. An underlying gentleness that contrasted starkly with his size and the stiff set of his shoulders.


- “He want to save everyone,” he finally said. “I tell him. People die. We save who we can. God take the rest.” He shook his head. “But he not listen. Feel guilty. Like it his fault.”
note: abraham's cousin alice dies in childbirth despite dr. jensen's heroic efforts, but at least he gets to bond with jared about it


- Inside one of the media trailers, Jared sat scanning through photos on his laptop. He’d taken hundreds of shots of people in the camp: families sharing a meal, mothers holding their children, men with angry, distant faces glaring at him through the lens. And the colors were amazing. Clothes hanging on makeshift lines strung between tents, blowing in the breeze like fall leaves. The slash of white smiles. Incongruous gray eyes in a dark face. A collection of half-melted prayer candles sitting in a hardened puddle of colored wax. The brilliant red, white, and blue of the American flag on a little boy’s t-shirt.

They were good photos. Evocative and descriptive. Balanced and well-framed. But they weren’t special. They weren’t original. There were a thousand, a million others just like them that had already been seen in papers across the country, across the world, on the Internet.


- Moose snorted a laugh, refocusing his gaze on Jared’s face. “I know the feeling,” he said. “Ever hear the expression, ‘I spent a week there one night’? That’s what it’s like in this place. It changes you. The way you think.” He tapped his right temple. “I’m beginning to worry that my kid won’t even recognize me when he sees me.” He reached across the table and pulled the remains of Jared’s breakfast towards him. Picking up the fork, he speared a greasy glob and put it in his mouth. “Time moves differently here,” he said, chewing slowly. “It’s like…I don’t know…like the earthquake altered the space-time continuum or something. Made people’s perceptions shift and stretch somehow.”


- Jimmy was gone, having been dragged away by a young woman who’d jabbered away in rapid Creole as she dragged the boy into the house.
note: jimmy is a small boy who doesn't speak english and has never seen a camera who is fascinated with jared


- “The Alamo? The Big Country? The Magnificent Seven?” Jared looked up at Abraham in surprise, motioning to the collection of VHS tapes inside the open trunk at the end of Abraham’s cot. “Where’d you get these?”

Abraham grinned, pride shining in his dark eyes. “Father Jerome,” he said. “He give them to me. Say they help me learn English.”

Jensen laughed. He was sitting on the empty cot of Abraham’s missing tent mate. “Abraham wants to be a cowboy,” he said.


- Through the lens, he studied Jensen’s face. He looked focused and relaxed. Confident. For all of Jensen’s insecurities, he was good at his job. And he seemed to be in his element here, in this place where it wasn’t all about money and status and golf handicaps. People trusted him here; Jared saw it everywhere they went. Jensen had a way of putting people around him at ease that he didn’t realize he had.


- The woman turned her eyes towards Abraham. When Abraham nodded, she looked back at Jensen. Smiling, she motioned with the tiny baby cradled in her arms. “Bebe mwen,” she said. “Jen-sen?”

“She ask me your name,” Abraham said, smiling. “She want to name baby after you.”
note: this is the third young, petite woman with a baby whose dialogue consists primarily of "bebe mwen"


- " My residency came to an end and a buddy of mine pitched this idea to go into private practice together. So we did. And before I realized it, I was entrenched. I had the house and the car and the pool and all the fucking forks. Then one day, I looked around at my life and realized I had become my parents. And for the life of me, I couldn’t remember how the hell it happened. So when the earthquake struck…god help me, I was grateful. I looked at it as an opportunity to get back on track. As a second chance to repay Josh for everything he’d done for me.” He took a breath, clearing his throat. “So here I am. Trying to make it up to him. I haven’t done a very good job so far, but I keep trying. That’s why I’m still here.”

Jared took two steps and kneeled down in front of Jensen, resting his hands on Jensen’s thighs. “Listen to me,” he said. “That may be the reason you came here, but it’s not the reason you stay. Say what you want about needing to repay a debt, you’re still here because you want to be. You care about these people, Jensen. And not just because you think you’re supposed to or because it’s what your brother would have done. I’ve seen you work. You’re a good doctor. You want to help these people. So what if you only became a doctor out of a sense of loyalty to your brother? That doesn’t mean you’re not allowed to love it.” He reached up and wrapped one hand around the back of Jensen’s neck, pressing their foreheads together. “And I’m right, aren’t I? You love it.”

It took a moment, but Jensen finally answered. “Yes.” Jared felt the word as a breath against his lips.

Jared closed his eyes. “Then please stop punishing yourself for it.” He curled his fingers in Jensen’s short hair.


- Abraham chuckled. “Go now,” he said, looking past Jensen to the security checkpoint and back again. “Go home. Rest.” He grinned. “Go to Disneyland.” He made a sweeping motion with his hand. “Haiti still be here if you want to come back.”

Jensen nodded. Come back. He hadn’t thought of that. Maybe he would someday. “Disneyland isn’t half as exciting as this place,” he said.


- Jensen slowly made his way down the concourse, gawking at the bustle around him. The symbols of progress. He hadn’t really been gone that long in real time, but somehow it felt like another lifetime ago, like he’d been living in an earlier decade, an earlier century. Everything here was immediate, right at your fingertips. Instant gratification. He thought about where he’d just come from. Nothing there was easy. Nothing there was instant. There were no celebrity magazines shouting gossip at you as you walked by. No complicated coffee and chocolate biscotti.


- “What the fuck is wrong with you? You got a tapeworm or something?” Scott grinned at Jensen from an arm’s length away, squeezing Jensen’s shoulders.

“I was in Haiti, Scott,” Jensen said, smirking. “I lived in a refugee camp. There weren’t any buffets.”

“Well, you look like shit,” Scott said, letting go of Jensen and taking a step back. “I’m surprised they didn’t quarantine you at the airport.”


- Abraham watched the cab turn into traffic, then turned to grin at Jared. “Jensen say I bad driver,” he said. “But American drivers crazy.”

Jared laughed. “He wasn’t American, Abraham,” he said, grinning back.


AND THE BEST PART FOR LAST:

Jared pointed at the cat, who was still just sitting there on the dresser, tail curved around his paws, a serene, unblinking expression on his little cat face. “That’s what cats do, Jensen. They judge. Sure, they purr and pretend to love you, but really, they’re plotting your death.” He lowered his hand. “Tell me again why you couldn’t get a dog.”

Jensen just looked at him. “Because I have you.”

Jared stuck his tongue out. Jensen smiled.

“Besides,” Jensen added, sliding up Jared’s body and pressing his lips to Jared’s shoulder. “I have a soft spot for strays. Especially ones who just show up on my doorstep one day and refuse to leave.” He rested his chin on Jared’s chest and gazed up at him with clear eyes.

Jared smiled and ran a hand through Jensen’s messy hair. “At least I’m housebroken.”

Jensen’s lips twisted into a smirk. “So is he. And he eats less.”

“But why did you have to name him Abraham?”

Jensen shifted, stretching out beside Jared and settling within the circle of Jared’s arm. He rested his head on Jared’s shoulder, sighing as Jared’s fingers absently traced the dark lines of his tattoo.

“Do you really have to ask?” he said, looking over at the cat. “I mean, look at him.”

Jared studied the cat again. It was the largest black cat he’d ever seen outside of Animal Planet, with paws bigger than those old Eisenhower silver dollars Jared used to collect when he was a kid. And he did always look like he was just on the verge of smiling.
skywardprodigal: Beautiful seated woman, laughing, in Vlisco. (Default)

[personal profile] skywardprodigal 2010-06-16 04:18 pm (UTC)(link)
I don't think people like that would care even if they DID conceive of Haitians being on the net and in fandom, because their friends/fans are not Haitians and therefore the likelihood of interacting with a Real! Live! Haitian is remote at best.

Yeah.

That sentence you quoted sent me straight for the wine bottle.

*hugs*

It hurt so much to read the first time. Taught me racism was thriving back when I thought fairness was a universal cultural value and educated people didn't speak and spread hate. :(
blue_gold: (BTVS BFF)

But whatever, its not like a Haitian will see this.

[personal profile] blue_gold 2010-06-17 02:36 pm (UTC)(link)
Raises hand as a HAITIAN in fandom. First off, most Haitians speak french. And her "bebe mwen" ugh. just Ugh.


The "broken" English hurts my brain. The idea that this is okay MONTHS later hurts my brain. The fact that this was written even before that and included photos hurts my brain.

NO ONE in her entire circle thought hey, wait problem? I want to throw things.

I think what peeves me the most is that this story could have been told and told well. With just a bit of research and treating Haiti and Haitians like you know a country and a people and not scenery and props. And its not that HARD. if you want to tell the story of two dudes falling in love and don't want to deal with background people make it an effing personal tragedy.

Suddenly we have a doctor and a photographer lost in the forests of Montana, both trying to: get back to their groups/civilization or hiding/running. You can even have a group of wounded campers or something if you need Jensen to work his doctor magic. Leave Haiti or the next nation that suffers a tragedy out of it. Because this. This is a failure on so many levels.

Re: But whatever, its not like a Haitian will see this.

(Anonymous) 2010-06-18 01:16 pm (UTC)(link)
hi.
"And her "bebe mwen" ugh. just Ugh."

Is it ugh because it's corny/stupid/overused dialog or because it is incorrect?


It seems that "bebe mwen" is overused/lame dialog in the story, but is it also incorrect? Does it actually mean "my baby"?
blue_gold: (Eris)

Re: But whatever, its not like a Haitian will see this.

[personal profile] blue_gold 2010-06-19 03:46 pm (UTC)(link)
It does mean "my baby" but it can be said a variety of different ways and at first glance my mind said but its a baby not a shirt, but that may be my own particular learning quirk.

"Bebe-m" would be my preferred expression for "my baby" same for my friend, mother, brother etc... mwen would be left to my shirt, book, car. But at the same time others words that mean child, baby, offspring I would be okay with Mwen it was a little bit of that and a lot of there are a ton of ways to say that learn more than two words or don't use the language.

Especially since research or watching one or two news reports would have shown french speakers were doing just fine, so were SPANISH speakers and the translators were really with those who only spoke English. But there I go demanding RESEARCH again.

But "my baby (child/Kid)" (spelling is highly iffy and mostly an attempt to get the sound right) Mwen=Mmwhen sorta.
Bebe Mwen
Bebe-mm
petite mwen
Petite pam
ti-moon mwen
ti-moon pam
hell I've even heard my non English speaking grandma throw out the word kid and I've just blinked at her.

Also? Jensen? REALLY EASY to pronounce. And Abraham's 'broken' English would be because he was following French/Creole grammar/syntax rules in English, you know the MOST common mistake anyone NEW to a language makes? Not dropping random words.

I hope that is a little more coherent.
skywardprodigal: Beautiful seated woman, laughing, in Vlisco. (Default)

Re: But whatever, its not like a Haitian will see this.

[personal profile] skywardprodigal 2010-06-20 01:13 am (UTC)(link)
First off, most Haitians speak french.

Not in my experience. Pale franse pa di lespri pou sa.

And its not that HARD. if you want to tell the story of two dudes falling in love and don't want to deal with background people make it an effing personal tragedy.

*nods*

With just a bit of research and treating Haiti and Haitians like you know a country and a people and not scenery and props.

Yeppers.

This is a failure on so many levels.

It's a flower of civilization. 'minds me of the fragrance of strange fruit.

Tout moun pa moun isn't just for reproducing oppression IN Haiti. It's handy if you're going to display a disconnect from human beings when you're not Haitian.
Edited 2010-06-20 01:18 (UTC)